255 Evelyn Dr

Pleasant Hill

3 Bed | 3.5 Bath | 2,419 Sq Ft

Offered at $1,375,000


A 1911 Original, Recast for Modern Living

Also on this level, a private office offers a dedicated space for work, while a powder room, in-home laundry, and direct interior access to the private one-car garage make everyday living remarkably seamless.

Upstairs, two bedrooms each enjoy their own ensuite bathroom, creating a comfortable separation between private spaces and the home’s more social main level. Between the second and third floors, a landing opens onto an exterior balcony deck—a tucked-away outdoor moment that offers neighborhood views and a natural place to pause.

The entire third floor is reserved for the primary suite, creating a private retreat at the top of the home. A generous sitting area provides room to read, lounge, or simply unwind before entering the luxurious ensuite bath. Here, a freestanding soaking tub, separate walk-in shower, double vanity, and heated tile floors create a distinctly elevated sense of comfort.

And beneath all of this is a entirely new modern infrastructure. The residence has been rebuilt from the studs with new plumbing, electrical, heating and air conditioning, seismic reinforcement, new shear walls, fire sprinklers, roof, gutters, insulation, and dual-pane low-E windows. Additional soundproofing between residences further enhances the sense of privacy and comfort.

There is something particularly compelling about a historic home that doesn’t simply preserve the past, but gives it a completely new life. Originally constructed as a church in 1911, this extraordinary three-level residence has been comprehensively reconstructed from the inside out, thoughtfully balancing original character with the comforts and precision of contemporary design.

At the heart of the home is its history. Douglas fir framing, roof rafters, and other structural lumber from the original church were carefully reclaimed rather than discarded. The wood was resawn into finish-grade material and reincorporated throughout the residence as custom wainscoting, baseboards, window and door trim, and other Craftsman-inspired details. Original tongue-and-groove Douglas fir flooring was likewise removed, preserved, refinished, and reinstalled, retaining the markings, variation, and century-old patina that make the material feel distinctly of its time.

The main level is conceived as one expansive living environment, with kitchen, dining, and living spaces flowing together beneath dramatic 14- to 16-foot ceilings. A fireplace anchors the living room, while the kitchen serves as the social center of the floor, finished with custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, a generous island with eating bar, and a range framed by a bespoke Zellige-tile alcove. A pot filler and new stainless-steel appliances bring considered functionality to the space without compromising its architectural character.

Just beyond the front door, the energy of Temescal is close at hand. The home is steps from the neighborhood’s lively mix of restaurants, cafés, shops, and everyday conveniences, while nearby McArthur BART makes commuting throughout the Bay Area remarkably easy. With quick access to major freeways, San Francisco is also within easy reach—offering the rare combination of an intimate residential setting and effortless connection to the city.

The result is a home that feels both deeply rooted and entirely of the moment—where original materials and Craftsman details meet thoughtful contemporary design, and where the architecture creates an experience that unfolds naturally across three levels. With exceptional attention to craftsmanship, modern infrastructure throughout, and one of Oakland’s most vibrant neighborhoods just outside the door, this is a residence that honors where it came from while looking confidently toward what comes next.

Step Inside

Experience the Home Beyond the First Impression

Take an immersive 3D tour to discover the flow, craftsmanship, and details that make this property truly unique.

Key Property Features

Discover the Flow &

Function

Neighborhood Standouts

Upcoming Open Houses

September 19th

2:00 - 4:00

September 26th

2:00 - 4:00

September 20th

2:00 - 4:00

September 27th

2:00 - 4:00